The Playbook
PricingPricing guide for every trade →

Time and Materials vs Fixed Price: Which Should You Quote?

Short answer

With time and materials you bill the hours you actually work plus materials, so the customer carries the risk of the job running long; with a fixed price you quote one number up front, so you carry that risk and keep the upside when you're fast. Use fixed prices for work you can estimate well and time and materials for work with real unknowns, like repairs behind walls.

Get every pricing calculator for your trade, free. Plus a group of owners who compare prices and swap referrals. Free to join, no card.

Or take the free 60-second pricing check

By the Growvio team 3 min read

In this article
  1. The short version
  2. How time and materials works
  3. How a fixed price works
  4. The same job, priced both ways
  5. When to use time and materials
  6. When to use a fixed price
  7. FAQ

Every job gets priced one of two ways: you bill for the time and materials it actually takes, or you agree on a fixed price before you start. Neither is better everywhere. The question is who should carry the risk of the job running long.

The short version

Time and materials Fixed price
What the customer pays Hours worked x your rate, plus materials One price agreed up front
Who carries the risk of overruns The customer You
Who keeps the gain if you're fast The customer You
Best for Repairs, diagnostics, work with unknowns Work you've done many times and can estimate
What customers prefer Less, they can't budget More, they know the number

How time and materials works

You agree on an hourly rate and how materials are billed (at cost, or with a markup). Then you track hours and receipts and bill what the job actually took. Your hourly rate has to cover your pay, overhead and profit, because there's nothing else in the bill to cover them. The hourly rate calculator works out that rate.

How a fixed price works

You estimate materials, labor hours, overhead and profit, and quote one number. If the job takes longer, your profit shrinks. If you're faster, you keep the difference. The job pricing calculator builds a fixed price from your costs and the margin you want.

The same job, priced both ways

Example numbers: $400 of materials and an estimated 10 labor hours.

Fixed price: labor costs you $40 an hour, overhead is 25% and you want a 30% margin. Cost: ($400 + 10 x $40) x 1.25 = $1,000. Price: $1,000 / 0.70 = $1,428.57.

Time and materials: you bill $95 an hour and mark materials up 20% ($480).

Hours the job really takes Time and materials bill Your margin on the fixed price
8 $1,240 37.0%
10 $1,430 30.0%
13 $1,715 19.5%

When the job runs to 13 hours, the time and materials bill grows with it. At the fixed price, your cost rises to $1,150 and your margin falls from 30% to 19.5%. When you finish in 8 hours, the fixed price earns you 37% and the customer would have paid less on time and materials.

That's the whole trade: fixed prices reward you for estimating well and working fast, and punish you when the estimate is wrong.

Is your pricing leaking money? Free 60-second check, five questions. Answers stay in your browser.

Question 1 of 5

Or your average take per hour on jobs.

$/hr

When to use time and materials

  • Repairs and diagnostics where you can't see the problem until you open it up
  • Old houses, hidden damage, or anything behind walls and under floors
  • Jobs where the customer keeps changing the scope
  • Small jobs where writing a detailed estimate costs more than the job

Many contractors use a not-to-exceed cap with time and materials, so the customer has a ceiling and you're still paid for real time up to it.

When to use a fixed price

  • Work you've done many times and can time accurately
  • Customers who need a number to decide or to get financing
  • Competitive bids, where a clear price wins
  • When you're faster than average and want to be paid for it

Build a buffer into the estimate for the unknowns you know about, and write down what's included so changes become change orders, not free work. The guide to the best way to bid a job walks through building a fixed price.

FAQ

Is time and materials or fixed price better for contractors? It depends on how well you can estimate the job. Fixed price is better when you can estimate accurately and work efficiently; time and materials is better when the job has real unknowns.

Can I combine the two? Yes. A common mix is a fixed price for the defined scope plus time and materials for anything extra, or time and materials with a not-to-exceed cap.

Do customers prefer fixed prices? Usually, because they can budget and compare. That's why many contractors quote fixed prices for routine work and keep time and materials for repairs.

How do I stop losing money on fixed-price jobs? Track your real hours on every job type and update your estimates, add a buffer for known unknowns, and price changes as change orders.

Run your numbers: the free job pricing calculator builds a fixed price from your own costs and margin. No sign-up.

Every pricing calculator and guide for your trade, free.

Hourly rate, job pricing, markup and hiring calculators for the trades, plus a free group of owners who run the same kind of business. Free to join, no card.

Free to join. No credit card.

Keep reading