When you need help, one of the first questions is whether to hire an employee (W-2) or pay a contractor (1099). The cost difference is real, but it's not a free choice: the law decides which one a worker is, based on how the work is done.
The short version
| W-2 employee | 1099 contractor | |
|---|---|---|
| Who pays Social Security and Medicare | You pay 7.65%, the employee pays 7.65% | The contractor pays all 15.3% (self-employment tax) |
| Unemployment taxes | You pay federal and state | None |
| Workers' comp | You carry it | Usually the contractor's responsibility |
| Benefits | Optional, if you offer them | None |
| Who controls how the work is done | You | The contractor |
What a W-2 employee really costs
On top of the wage, an employer pays:
- Employer FICA: 7.65% (6.2% Social Security up to the yearly wage base, plus 1.45% Medicare)
- FUTA: 6.0% on the first $7,000 of wages, usually reduced to 0.6% by the state credit, about $42 a year
- State unemployment (SUTA): varies by state and your history
- Workers' comp: varies a lot by trade and state
Worked example: $25 an hour, full time
These are example rates. Use the ones on your own payroll and policy.
| Line | Yearly |
|---|---|
| Wages ($25 x 2,080 hours) | $52,000 |
| Employer FICA (7.65%) | $3,978 |
| FUTA | $42 |
| SUTA (2% example) | $1,040 |
| Workers' comp ($4 per $100 example) | $2,080 |
| Total required cost | $59,140 |
That's $28.43 per paid hour, about 13.7% on top of the wage, before any paid time off, health insurance or retirement. Add benefits and small employers average about 35% on top of pay, per BLS figures. The employee cost calculator runs this with your numbers, and the labor burden calculator shows the burdened hourly cost to price from.
What a 1099 contractor costs
Only what you agree to pay. The contractor pays their own self-employment tax (15.3% on most of their net earnings), their own insurance and their own tools. That's why contractors usually charge more per hour than the same person would earn as an employee: on $52,000 of earnings, self-employment tax alone is about $7,347.
So the hourly gap is often smaller than it looks. Compare the contractor's rate to the employee's full cost per hour, not to the wage.
Is your pricing leaking money? Free 60-second check, five questions. Answers stay in your browser.
The rule that decides: classification
You can't pick 1099 just because it's cheaper. The IRS looks at behavioral control (do you control how the work is done?), financial control (do they have their own tools, other clients, a chance of profit or loss?) and the relationship (is it ongoing and core to your business?). Some states, such as California, use a stricter test. Misclassifying an employee can mean back taxes, penalties and back wages.
A helper who works your schedule, uses your tools and does your core work is usually an employee. A licensed sub with their own business, tools and other clients, hired for a defined job, is usually a contractor. When it's unclear, ask your accountant or check the IRS guidance on independent contractor or employee.
Which is cheaper for your business?
Compare like with like:
- Work out the employee's full hourly cost, including payroll taxes, workers' comp and any benefits.
- Divide by the hours they'd actually spend on billable work, not just hours paid.
- Compare that to the contractor's rate for the same billable work.
The guide to what to pay a service tech and the guide to when to hire your first employee go deeper on the hire itself.
FAQ
Is a 1099 contractor cheaper than a W-2 employee? Often per hour of help, because you don't pay payroll taxes, workers' comp or benefits. But contractors usually charge more per hour, and you can only use 1099 when the worker genuinely qualifies as independent.
How much more does a W-2 employee cost than their wage? Required costs alone were about 13.7% on top of the wage in our example. With benefits, BLS figures put small private employers at about 35% on top of pay.
Who pays taxes on a 1099 contractor? The contractor pays their own income tax and self-employment tax. You report payments to them on a 1099 form at year end if they meet the IRS threshold.
Can I switch an employee to 1099 to save money? Not if the work stays the same. Classification depends on how the work is done, not on what you'd prefer to pay. Talk to your accountant before changing anyone's status.
Run your numbers: the free employee cost calculator shows what a hire really costs per month and per hour. No sign-up.