Swapping a toilet is a common call for handymen and plumbers. It's quick when everything goes right, and slow when the flange is cracked, the shutoff valve won't close or the bolts are rusted solid.
Check the rules first
Rules vary. Some places let a handyman do a like-for-like toilet swap; others require a licensed plumber for any plumbing work. Moving the drain or adding a new line is plumber work. Check your local rules before you quote.
The formula
- Know your hourly rate. The handyman hourly rate calculator (or the plumbing hourly rate calculator) works it out.
- Time the whole job: drive, shutting off and draining, removing the old toilet, cleaning the flange, setting the new one, connecting, testing and cleanup.
- Add parts: wax ring or foam seal, closet bolts, supply line.
- Add haul-away if you take the old toilet.
Worked example
This uses an example rate of $101.37 an hour, from the hourly rate calculator with a $60,000 wage, $600 a month for health insurance, $24,000 of overhead and 1,050 billable hours a year.
- Swap a customer-supplied toilet: about 1.75 hours ($177.40) plus $25 of parts = $202.40.
- Haul the old one away: about 15 more minutes ($25.34) plus a $10 disposal fee, so $237.74 in total.
The plumbing estimate calculator prices bigger plumbing jobs from parts, labor and overhead.
Is your pricing leaking money? Free 60-second check, five questions. Answers stay in your browser.
Surprises to price for
- A cracked or corroded flange: a repair ring or a new flange adds time and parts.
- A shutoff valve that won't close: replacing it is a separate fix.
- Rusted bolts: cutting them out takes time.
- A floor that isn't level: shims and extra setting time.
Tell the customer up front that these are priced separately if they come up, so nobody is surprised.
Supplying the toilet
If you supply the toilet, add its cost and the pickup time. Many customers prefer to pick the model themselves; quote the install either way.
Related pricing guides
Pricing a similar job? See How Much to Charge for Ceiling Fan Installation and How Much Should a Plumber Charge Per Hour? (Worked Example), or run your own numbers in the plumbing estimate calculator.
Check the rest of your pricing
The free 60-second Profit Leak Check shows whether your hourly rate covers your pay, overhead and profit, and whether your markup keeps what you think.
Meet other owners
Handymen and plumbers send each other the jobs that fit the other one better. Growvio is a free group where home-service owners swap referrals and what's working. Join free, it takes about a minute.
FAQ
How much should I charge to install a toilet? Your hourly rate times the real install time, plus parts and haul-away. At $101.37 an hour, a swap comes to $202.40 with parts.
Should I charge to haul away the old toilet? Yes. It's extra time and a disposal fee. In the example, it brings the total to $237.74.
Can a handyman install a toilet? It depends on where you work. Some places allow like-for-like swaps; others require a licensed plumber.
What if the flange is damaged? Price the repair separately, and tell the customer before you start that it might come up.
Run your numbers: the free handyman hourly rate calculator works out the rate behind every price. No sign-up.